Some parents feel teachers talk down to them and look on them as if they are not very intelligent. “Sometimes it’s not the fault of the parents, it’s the attitude of the teacher. Often the best teachers can relate to children, but don’t cope very well with adults."I have to admit that there have been times during my many years of parenting when I have been considered a "difficult parent", and although I've not been aggressive, I most certainly have been assertive and demanding. From where I sit, that is part of my job as a mom.
PTA: Parent Teacher Adversaries?
About Sandra Hanks Benoiton
Similar entries
Popular by Sandra
"It's their job to teach, and it's our job to make sure they're doing that well." Amen.
The best advice I got about helping my child in school was that I need to be my child's advocate b/c no one else was going to take that role. The advice came from a teacher at my child's school and mother of 4. She could be considered a saint as she never, ever made a mistake but she also realized that other teachers, even great ones, were not so diligent. She helped me get my child out of a so-so to bad situation and one of his teachers (a wonderful person but not terribly qualified) did not return to his school.
I fully support teachers even when they are not perfect...almost all of the time. I did have to push back with one of my son's teachers last year, something I hated to do but I felt that she needed to understand that she was going to have a battle if she was going to push my son around. Being a nice southern woman though, I did it a sickeningly sweet way that managed to get my point across.
You seem to be jumping to the same conclusion that you accuse the teachers of doing only in reverse, "blame the teacher"I can see how important it would be to "learn to deal with aggressive parents" especially at a kindergarden level. As long as people hold the mentality that "they work for us" I imagine there will continue to be a need for such training. It would be far more beneficial to realize that parents and teachers are working together for their children. Sadly there are far more negligent parents out there than there are good ones.
We didn't identify my son's Aspergers, ADD and dyslexic profile until just before grade 5. Instead, his inability to learn social cues, black-and-white nature, difficulty with spelling, resistance to transitions, restlessness, etc., were all 'my fault.' His ability to read at a fourth grade level was due to the teachers, of course...
I'm sorry for the teachers, who were working with what they thought was just a defiant neurotypical kid. I'm sorry for me, labeled as a completely ineffective parent who couldn't discipline worth dust. And I'm sorry for my boy, who likes to learn as long as it has nothing to do with school. He's stuck there for another 7-8 years minimum.
I'm hoping to get an IEP established, so he won't be a surprise to all of his future teachers too. I'm hoping they'll be able to respond to him with the ways that work, and that he'll respond in turn by trusting them. I'm hoping that we can all help him learn how to cope, how to get his needs met, and how to excel. It'll take a team effort, and I really want to be an effective part of this team.
I suppose it's all in how you define negligent. In my sons class, about 10% of the parents are vigilantly active in with the school. There is also probably 5 to 10% of those kids who already at kindergarten show no signs of living a productive lifestyle. It's sad, the bad parenting gleams through strongly with them. As for the rest of the class, probably the average parents. I find it hard to believe that when most people don't research anything they buy whether it be a home mortgage or health insurance, who also don't consider what kind of food they feed their kids with their nightly microwavable meals, and those who allow toddlers to watch entirely too much television, that caring about their child's education should be any different to them. Why not blame the parent?
I am a 5th grade teacher who has taught public, private, high socio-economic, low socio-economic and in an American school overseas.
I heartily agree that there are incompetent teachers who do a grave disservice to kids and to the parents of those kids. I also heartily agree that there are parents who, for whatever reason, don't do their children justice.
I consider myself to be and have been told by various administrators that I am an above average teacher. I love my students and want the very best for them. I continually seek feedback on my skills and attend professional development to learn new strategies. I go to school each day reminding myself that my kiddos don't get this day back. They don't get a do over if I am not at my best that day. However, this year I had a parent who removed her child from my class because she did not believe I was best for her child. Does she bear some responsibility in her child's academic weaknesses? I believe so. Does her child work to manipulate the situation and tell only half the story? I believe so. Does that mean the mom was wrong to have her child moved? NO! This mother was doing what she should do - advocating for her child the best way she knows how. I bear no hard feelings because maybe my colleague (who is outstanding) can reach this child in a way I couldn't.
In the end, it is not about the teacher or the parent, but the child. What is best for the child should be the guiding force for all parties concerned. I don't see parents as adversaries but as a great resource for me in helping their children.
Unfortunately, dyslexia and ADD alone don't qualify for an IEP and an autism spectrum disorder like Asperger's since it is high-functioning doesn't easily qualify either. If you are not successful in getting an IEP, think about a 504 plan. It is part of the American's with Disabilities Act and can provide for classroom accommodations and modifications for children who don't qualify for an IEP.
Good luck.
As someone who went to college to become a teacher, then quit to have babies, then decided to homeschool them, I fall on both sides of this dilemma. My husband is going to be a teacher next year, and we have talked about this often. It isn't until you've been both a teacher AND a parent that you can fully grasp the responsibility that lies on both sides. I think, however, that Sandra communicates the situation quite fairly and eloquently.
As long as our children spend an increasing amount of time with the teachers and less with the parents, there will be more expectations and responsibility placed on the schools. The ONLY way to avoid this problem entirely is to educate them yourself. Just as there are a few teachers not qualified to train a rabbit, there are some parents not fit to raise a flagpole. Communication is the FIRST step in this much-needed "meeting of the minds."
Thanks Sandra for this great post!
Email this
Subscribe
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Technorati
Subscribe to our full text feed via RSS or email
Subscribe
Subscribe
Comments